Whilst I love both and would be absolutely over the moon if someone bought me a Rogue for Christmas (dream on Sweetie!), I would buy the Nomad if I were in your shoes. I love the Nomad leather, and I think the classic style of it means you will absolutely love it forever, and possibly more over time. The Rogue is still riding on its hype, but time will tell if it can outlive that, and you may fall out of love with the snake handles.