Ring Choice-Pigeons Blood Ruby or Art Deco Fancy Diamond

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

Congratulations on your new ring! I'm late for the vote, but would vote for the OMC diamond in AD setting! I have RHR with OMC in lower color and love it every day more and more, especially for the color :biggrin: and chunky facets!
 
  • Like
Reactions: efleon
Congrats! Glad you decided on the diamond!

For what it’s worth, if the fact the ruby was a “pigeon blood” that made you want to get it, in the end, gemstones are very personal. I am a colored gemstone lover and got caught up in what was the “best”, and I had a certified unheated Burma Pigeon Blood ruby, a deep green certified no oil Colombian emerald, blah blah blah...

I have since discovered I like my rubies stop-light bright red (no blue), and I like my emeralds Palmolive glow green (not dark, minimal blue).

I share this with you as I’ve made costly mistakes in the past as to what people think is the best.

In the end, the best is what puts an ear to ear grin on your face when you look at it.

I just wanted to share my thoughts and hope it helped to clear any doubt about your decision.

Congrats again on a great piece of bling!
 
Congrats! Glad you decided on the diamond!

For what it’s worth, if the fact the ruby was a “pigeon blood” that made you want to get it, in the end, gemstones are very personal. I am a colored gemstone lover and got caught up in what was the “best”, and I had a certified unheated Burma Pigeon Blood ruby, a deep green certified no oil Colombian emerald, blah blah blah...

I have since discovered I like my rubies stop-light bright red (no blue), and I like my emeralds Palmolive glow green (not dark, minimal blue).

I share this with you as I’ve made costly mistakes in the past as to what people think is the best.

In the end, the best is what puts an ear to ear grin on your face when you look at it.

I just wanted to share my thoughts and hope it helped to clear any doubt about your decision.

Congrats again on a great piece of bling!
Yes! I was caught up in the “perfect-ness” of the Burma ruby!!! My thinking was gee whiz, this is really a great classy way to curate my jewelry collection since I don’t have a ruby or an emerald. And the color was amazing. But the overall (relatively) small size of the ring underwhelmed me. I was more in love with the specs of that ring than the actual ring when it was on my finger!!!
So thank you for pointing that out.
 
Personally, I am a fan of Art Deco style in general and I think it compliments your hand more than the ruby. Ruby’s density is higher than sapphires and diamonds so their 1 carat is even smaller than the 1 carat you would expect from a diamond or a sapphire. For me it would be too little of a stone, even though the quality i you described of this stone is obviously great.
 
  • Like
  • Love
Reactions: 880 and efleon
Top