I don’t think it’s silly to ask. It’s not like she commented under a reseller’s post and asked them “hey can you actually sell this bag to me for what you paid? Xx”. She literally just asked if anyone is, or is willing to sell a bag for what they paid and did very clear state no resellers, probably to avoid the drama that ensued anyway.
An open request is very different from a targeted request. Those resellers and the people defending them are just pathetic because they could’ve scrolled past and made no comment. Simple as.
And notice how that person asked to be sold an old Chanel bag for the original price it was paid … not less than what it was paid for because it was used. OP was doing them a favor, but greedy resellers and the customers that buy from them were offended by some common sense.
There’s something very wrong with that scenario.
Imagine if one day Chanel goes out of mainstream fashion. Then we’ll see if Chanel bags actually hold their value like property

?!
Like they’re literally just pieces of leather and metal thrown together whoes value depends very heavily on the brand value. Whilst The value of property can be variable too at least it’s a necessity good that actually derives a lot of value from the value of the land it’s on.
That’s a scary thought, lol.
Not all my bags scream “luxury brand logos” but when I carry them, I feel a sense of happiness and pride knowing that what I’m carrying is a
GUCCI or LV or Hermès … even if it’s discreet. Sometimes I see “dupes” on the market and, as shallow as it may sound, they don’t excite me as much as when I know I’m carrying the real thing.
I have seen gorgeous epi speedies on
fashionphile but many of them (especially the ones in Tassil, ivory or Cassis colors) are was overpriced for being over 20 years old. And I had enough self-control (as hard as it may be) to either wait for them to get down to at least below $500 (which is still above the price they were sold for in the 90s) or wait for a good deal.
If we all practiced some self control, resellers would respect us the customers more or even better, cease to exist.
So how effective do we think it is to report resellers’ names back to the boutique?
I get so frustrated being told that highly sought after items are waitlisted or reserved for clients when these individuals then just go and sell the items a couple of days later for profit to people who aren’t VIP enough to have a popular bag reserved for them. I have personally purchased items through the reseller market as a result of this, and have full details because of the receipts. Do we have the ability to slowly remove this problem (if Chanel plan to do anything with the information) or is there no point?
The only thing that can stop resellers doing what they do is if the clients stop buying from them.
Even if you report as certain reseller, they’ll still use other people to buy for them, family, friends … etc.
I believe some SAs are resellers themselves (once again could be using friends, family to buy for them so as to not raise suspicion).
We as the clients hold the power, stop encouraging this “reseller culture” and it will disappear altogether.