Replicas rant

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

You'd actually be surprised by how many people post videos of bag reviews, while explicitly stating they are replicas and how you can get one too. There's also an entire group on reddit dedicated for replicas. I remember seeing a thread on how to take a fake lv and its overly glossy canvas and I think lightly sand it to make it less glossy and more similar to the real thing. My jaw dropped at the cleverness and ridiculousness. If you're going through that much effort, just save for the real thing. We don't need every "it" item out there anyway.

I accidentally stumbled on one of those groups looking for info about a lv bag, and I literally could not believe how much people were spending on a fake. $200-300 for a speedy that they allege was '1:1'. Seriously? I've seen a slew of authentic ones on resale sites that are less than that. Sure the condition might not be great, but at the least they were authentic. You could always have lv or a local repairer refurbish it. I don't know what possesses people to spend this much on a replica. Status signaling ig? can't relate.

You never see a high-quality less conspicuous brand/design at those places. It's always those with a huge Gucci/LV/Goyard/YSL/etc logo. They claim they like it because of the 'design' lol. lbr these people wouldn't by a replica disco/speedy/st louis/Kate/etc bag if it didn't have a huge logo on it.
 
Nah there are dupes and then there are replicas. I am not against dupes because they don’t pretend to be the real thing but there are several that parade their replicas and don’t share the seller because they know it’s not legal. And they call it ‘my Chanel classic flap bag’ and it comes with full logo box dust bag and authenticity card with Chanel stamping and everything. It’s actually really common on YouTube if you see one you’ll see so many. I think that is completely unnecessary the lengths these fakes go to. Also some people purchase these to resell on like Facebook to dupe some undiscerning buyer. I’ve seen it too on marketplace


Ohh okay then that is something to be alarmed about. I’ve seen many videos talking about dupes and I think it’s perfectly fine. I’m not sure if I’d buy it because I prefer to see my bags I’m gonna get live.

I love going to department stores and look at the bags how they feel and everything. I prefer to buy, MIchael by Michael Kors, Coach, Rebecca Minkoff etc because I want to have my purse the day I buy it but if someone is happy getting dupe is a good deal.

Réplicas I don’t judge the ones who get them but I don’t think they are really getting a good deal for the price of an identical replica they can better get an original Michael Kors, Kate Spade or any contemporary bag.
There is no rush to make the jump to the luxury bags.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Shelby33
I don't have any tolerance for people who choose to wear fakes. Be it fake bags, shoes, watches, whatever.

I find the ubiquitous word 'replica' funny because it's so telling. Why would anyone call a fake handbag a replica? Because they don't like hearing the word 'fake'? Well, that's exactly what those items are, fakes. That should've been the first clue, that they shouldn't buy those items - they're not real, they don't have the same qualities an actual item they're copying has, and I don't mean just materials- or workmanship-wise.

I assume people who buy those fakes want them to compliment their look. In my eyes, fake stuff not just cheapens one's outfit, but completely ruins it. There's this old saying about fake watches being for fake people. I personally agree with it wholeheartedly. It doesn't matter if the people around can tell it's fake. Although I would assume in certain circles there will always be at least one person who will know it's fake just from looking at the item for three seconds. Those lies about 'wanting the look for less money' are ridiculous. You don't get the look by buying fake stuff, that's just how you get the fake look. Those who say they just don't want to worry about damaging an expensive item - why does it have to look like it's designer? Just buy a cheap bag that doesn't resemble a $1K+ designer piece and you're good to go.

There are SO MANY great brands out there that offer good enough quality for as low as $100. They often follow the current trends and/or classic styles, so if you want a flap bag on a chain, there's plenty of options to choose from. Don't get it in the diamond or chevron quilt - or if you really want to, get the quilt but in a different shape. It will not look like a Chanel, but it will still look nice.

You can even go pre-loved because eBay and other such platforms are full of nice used bags that are still in good condition but will run you as little as $20. In some countries, you can get nice pre-loved bags for even less than that. I have. There's absolutely no reason for anyone to buy a fake item unless they deliberately want to lie to people around them.

Also, I have seen some YouTube personalities voice their opinions on fakes that ran along the lines of, 'I don't endorse it but to each their own.' I always wonder when I hear this from YouTubers whether they really think that or just don't want to alienate some of their audiences. It's like trying to sit on two chairs. Either you're against fakes or you're not. Doesn't matter if you don't wear fake stuff yourself. I feel like if you're in media and producing content on fashion, you should be firmly against fakes in every way.

And I didn't even touch on the subject of child labor, sweatshops and where the money made from counterfeit items goes.
 
You'd actually be surprised by how many people post videos of bag reviews, while explicitly stating they are replicas and how you can get one too. There's also an entire group on reddit dedicated for replicas. I remember seeing a thread on how to take a fake lv and its overly glossy canvas and I think lightly sand it to make it less glossy and more similar to the real thing. My jaw dropped at the cleverness and ridiculousness. If you're going through that much effort, just save for the real thing. We don't need every "it" item out there anyway.
omg that is crazy!!!! I have stumbled on a reddit thread while I was looking for the elusive Chanel rose gold mini flap and the thread was reviewing a replica. It took me a while to even realise because they use codes and abbreviations lol
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Passerine123
I don't have any tolerance for people who choose to wear fakes. Be it fake bags, shoes, watches, whatever.

I find the ubiquitous word 'replica' funny because it's so telling. Why would anyone call a fake handbag a replica? Because they don't like hearing the word 'fake'? Well, that's exactly what those items are, fakes. That should've been the first clue, that they shouldn't buy those items - they're not real, they don't have the same qualities an actual item they're copying has, and I don't mean just materials- or workmanship-wise.

I assume people who buy those fakes want them to compliment their look. In my eyes, fake stuff not just cheapens one's outfit, but completely ruins it. There's this old saying about fake watches being for fake people. I personally agree with it wholeheartedly. It doesn't matter if the people around can tell it's fake. Although I would assume in certain circles there will always be at least one person who will know it's fake just from looking at the item for three seconds. Those lies about 'wanting the look for less money' are ridiculous. You don't get the look by buying fake stuff, that's just how you get the fake look. Those who say they just don't want to worry about damaging an expensive item - why does it have to look like it's designer? Just buy a cheap bag that doesn't resemble a $1K+ designer piece and you're good to go.

There are SO MANY great brands out there that offer good enough quality for as low as $100. They often follow the current trends and/or classic styles, so if you want a flap bag on a chain, there's plenty of options to choose from. Don't get it in the diamond or chevron quilt - or if you really want to, get the quilt but in a different shape. It will not look like a Chanel, but it will still look nice.

You can even go pre-loved because eBay and other such platforms are full of nice used bags that are still in good condition but will run you as little as $20. In some countries, you can get nice pre-loved bags for even less than that. I have. There's absolutely no reason for anyone to buy a fake item unless they deliberately want to lie to people around them.

Also, I have seen some YouTube personalities voice their opinions on fakes that ran along the lines of, 'I don't endorse it but to each their own.' I always wonder when I hear this from YouTubers whether they really think that or just don't want to alienate some of their audiences. It's like trying to sit on two chairs. Either you're against fakes or you're not. Doesn't matter if you don't wear fake stuff yourself. I feel like if you're in media and producing content on fashion, you should be firmly against fakes in every way.

And I didn't even touch on the subject of child labor, sweatshops and where the money made from counterfeit items goes.
I agree!! Exactly that there are so many alternative pieces with similar look by other brands if they liked the look of it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cate14
I just saw a review of a dupe Loewe Puzzle Bag and the first thing she mentioned was the smell... I'd rather smell real leather and get something more affordable.


I guess it depends which dupe you buy like with replicas there are different qualities of dupes. It’s reading the description in Amazon of the dupe you are gonna get.

There are dupes with real leather and some which are not. Since I heard about them I’ve checked them out and I’ve seen some on 40-60 dollars which are with faux leather and they say it and some running in the 100 dollars and those are from real leather.

I’ve never bought a dupe, I prefer inspired by from contemporary brands than dupes but I don’t think dupes are wrong.
 
Last edited:
I don't understand spending $500+ on a fake when you can get most luxury brands on consignment or second hand for the same price, sometimes even less. Even second hand a lot of times the bags come with dust bags or in pretty much brand new condition.
When I was doing some research on fakes of my absolute favorite bag ever (Proenza Schouler PS1), I found a 'Replica community' on Reddit where some woman was boasting her latest fake bag purchase, and she said she paid $300 for it. I laughed at part. Thankfully, Proenzas don't do all that well on the second-hand market and you can actually get a used, but still in good enough condition authentic PS1 for that money. Yet some people would rather buy a new fake.
wut?
 
  • Like
Reactions: pikaachuu
When I was doing some research on fakes of my absolute favorite bag ever (Proenza Schouler PS1), I found a 'Replica community' on Reddit where some woman was boasting her latest fake bag purchase, and she said she paid $300 for it. I laughed at part. Thankfully, Proenzas don't do all that well on the second-hand market and you can actually get a used, but still in good enough condition authentic PS1 for that money. Yet some people would rather buy a new fake.
wut?
Omgggggg that’s so dumb lol!! Major face palm
 
Sometimes you can luck out... I stumbled upon the exact givenchy shoes I had been drooling over (from this season) on poshmark and I guess someone had bought them and either didn't like them or they didnt fit but anyway they were never worn. I got them for less than half of retail... brand new and this season!

I've seen many bags on fashionphile in excellent condition for very good prices. I'm not really into vintage so the pieces are still a bit up in price but way less than retail and only within 2-3 years old. Vestiaire collective too. I've made offers and had them accepted and didnt expect them to agree... so there are options. And a few of those sites allow payments over several months too! So no excuses in my mind!
 
  • Like
Reactions: IntheOcean
Oh and speaking of dupes... the contemporary brands I consider dupes. They take the high end designs change them a teeny bit and slap their own logo. Example....

Michael Kors Manhattan
Screenshot_20190920-105004_Chrome.jpg
Meets Proenza Schouler PS1
Screenshot_20190920-105156_Chrome.jpg

Blatant!!!
But at least it's not an exact replica. But it's still stealing in my mind.
 
Oh and speaking of dupes... the contemporary brands I consider dupes. They take the high end designs change them a teeny bit and slap their own logo. Example....

Michael Kors Manhattan
View attachment 4544867
Meets Proenza Schouler PS1
View attachment 4544868

Blatant!!!
But at least it's not an exact replica. But it's still stealing in my mind.

I’d say the MK Manhattan looks more like a Philip Lim. This Provenza is more soft the Manhattan is much more structured
 
I agree. I own a PS1, and the Manhattan is “hard”. I want a Manhattan and don’t feel like I would be buying the same bag. The only thing holding me back is that it doesn’t have the top handle.
 
Nice
I agree. I own a PS1, and the Manhattan is “hard”. I want a Manhattan and don’t feel like I would be buying the same bag. The only thing holding me back is that it doesn’t have the top handle.

Yes it’s a really beautiful bag it’s on my wish list along with the Cece. Both from Michael Kors. Either of them is my next bag.
 
  • Like
Reactions: B4GBuff
Top