Michael Kors Quality; Michael Kors vs Coach

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

#31
I have both and find that Coach is better quality overall. Yes, Coach is becoming mass market fast, but so is MK. I have 2 mks and the Berkely is just so small inside and heavy for a smaller bag, its stiching is coming apart and mk after sales is horrible!

Coach repaired one bag with no questions asked and completely replaced one bag 5 months later for me! They amaze me with service.

I am trying to get rid of both lines now as I hardly use these bags now that I've discovered LV and Chanel...
 
#33
I think MK quality is horrible at least on my Hamilton. I have a red quilted Hamilton. The color on the corners is already worn off and I have only used this bag about 10 times total. The rest of the time this bag has been stored in it's dust bag. I will never buy MK again. My outlet coach bags have lasted tons longer than this.
 
#35
I think Coach has better quality overall with amazing customer service to boot. My sister's Michael Kors purse fell apart in less than a year of use. The strap on her bag started fraying really badly and the store didn't do anything to repair it, even though they pretended to... That said, I'm not really a big fan of the aesthetics of Coach purses, and prefer Michael Kors designs more. I'm thinking about purchasing a Hamilton large tote, but not sure if the quality is that great for the price. Anyone who has the tote fill me in? Thanks
 
#36
laurel234 said:
I think Coach has better quality overall with amazing customer service to boot. My sister's Michael Kors purse fell apart in less than a year of use. The strap on her bag started fraying really badly and the store didn't do anything to repair it, even though they pretended to... That said, I'm not really a big fan of the aesthetics of Coach purses, and prefer Michael Kors designs more. I'm thinking about purchasing a Hamilton large tote, but not sure if the quality is that great for the price. Anyone who has the tote fill me in? Thanks
Click to expand...

I have 3. So far, they have all worn just fine. I have 2 plain leather and one embossed. I haven't carried the croc embossed yet, so I can't say how that will wear. My plain leathers have done just fine. They break in a bit and get nice and soft. If you buy from MK, my SA said that if you ever have an issue to bring it in. They also have spare locks and whatnot hanging around.
 
#37
sandc said:
I have 3. So far, they have all worn just fine. I have 2 plain leather and one embossed. I haven't carried the croc embossed yet, so I can't say how that will wear. My plain leathers have done just fine. They break in a bit and get nice and soft. If you buy from MK, my SA said that if you ever have an issue to bring it in. They also have spare locks and whatnot hanging around.
Click to expand...


That is good to know... I lost the key for my LV lock at the LV store... and the only option is to cut the lock and I have to buy a new one for 40 bucks or leave it on the zipper. sigh...

Coach CS is amazing!!! Most places do not have CS like that anymore, that is one HUGE plus to buy Coach.
 
#38
I vote Coach. Especially because of the customer service. I have 4 Coach bags and 3 MK bags.

The first MK (I got for 25% of at about $350) had chain straps, gunmetal leather. The leather is fine, but after a couple of days I noticed the grommets on one of the links on the strap were missing. They fell off I surmise. I took it into the store to repair. They looked at me like I was crazy but took care of the issue in a few days.

My second MK bag is a Sloan tote/top handle bag. It was 50% off for $175. I was hesitant to buy it because the latch seemed to not close securely/easily. I raised the concern, the sales associate looked at and said it looked fine. Since it was an awesome price for a great shape/nice leather I decided to get it. It is a closure that is new to me, so I thought I just wasn't pushing it in all the way. Anyway. Got it home. Tried it a bit and it seemed fine. I decided to try it out one day. HA! They clasp popped open between me picking it up and walking the 15-20 feet to my front door. With the slightest agitation, or even with items pressing on the front of the bag as it sat on a table, it would pop open. It is currently at the store for repair.

My first Coach bag. I think it was some sort of Madison bag. After about 18 months, the handle broke. Well that isn't accurate. It was a rolled leather handle, and one of them broke in the middle and lost its firm structure. I took it in for repair. It wasn't repairable so I got a full credit for the bag.

Thus far, I have had mixed results with my MK bags. Considering the customer service isn't great, I don't feel like I should pay anywhere near full price. I might have to rethink my strategy, and avoid the boutique or outlet for the purchases. On the whole I like the classic American style of Coach and MK. They both offer practical organization systems (especially when compared to most other nicer bags).
 
#39
Hi, everyone! Since we're on this topic, I hope you could help me decide which one to get: the MK All-in-One Mercer bag (this one can be a backpack, satchel etc) or the Coach Benett (bandouliere style and if ever, should I get one in monogram or a plain one?) or do you think I should explore more on the Longchamp Le Pliage backpack or a Kate Spade Hilo backpack? PLEASE HELP I AM REALLY HAVING A MAJOR BAG DILEMMA HERE!
 
#40
striveforluxury said:
Hi, everyone! Since we're on this topic, I hope you could help me decide which one to get: the MK All-in-One Mercer bag (this one can be a backpack, satchel etc) or the Coach Benett (bandouliere style and if ever, should I get one in monogram or a plain one?) or do you think I should explore more on the Longchamp Le Pliage backpack or a Kate Spade Hilo backpack? PLEASE HELP I AM REALLY HAVING A MAJOR BAG DILEMMA HERE!
Click to expand...

The all-in-one Mercer bag is a great bag. However, it is rather small. Have you seen it in person? I was surprised at how compact it is and I like small bag. The Bennet is a nice satchel that's roomiwr than the Mercer. It's leather is not quite as nice as the Mercer's though. I prefer the leather on the Coach Lenox satchel. It is a lovely bag in a similar shape with yummy smushy leather. You should be able you should still be able find it easily at the outlets right now.
I would not get a monogram bag. I prefer leather to monogram any day. (But that's just me.)

Good luck with your decision!
 
#41
carterazo said:
The all-in-one Mercer bag is a great bag. However, it is rather small. Have you seen it in person? I was surprised at how compact it is and I like small bag. The Bennet is a nice satchel that's roomiwr than the Mercer. It's leather is not quite as nice as the Mercer's though. I prefer the leather on the Coach Lenox satchel. It is a lovely bag in a similar shape with yummy smushy leather. You should be able you should still be able find it easily at the outlets right now.
I would not get a monogram bag. I prefer leather to monogram any day. (But that's just me.)

Good luck with your decision!
Click to expand...

Thanks for sharing your thoughts! I have finally decided to get the Mercer :) and I searched the Lenox, I love it! Maybe next time if I do not opt for a higher end bag for my next purchase? Btw, I love your signature hahaha I also need a bag slap once in a while
 
  • Like
Reactions: carterazo
#43
I only have 2 MK bags (two Medium Mercer Duffels) but I am very pleased with them. Nice stitching, good structure, lots of interior pockets. I do plan to add another down the road (Large Jet Set Tote). I do not like their "no returns" policy for sale items though (at least here in Canada for their online site) since I would only buy their bags on sale! I have heard mixed reviews about their CS but have not had to deal with them myself.

All my Coach bags are from the Coach 1941 line and the quality is amazing (leather/suede linings, supple glovetanned leather, beautiful details) but I don't think it is fair to compare them to the MK bags I have as they also have a higher price point, though I have never paid FP. I was never interested in Coach until Coach 1941 so cannot speak to their regular line or outlet items. I have had great experiences with their customer service, and they take returns on sale items!
 
  • Like
Reactions: SEWDimples
#44
RayKay said:
I only have 2 MK bags (two Medium Mercer Duffels) but I am very pleased with them. Nice stitching, good structure, lots of interior pockets. I do plan to add another down the road (Large Jet Set Tote). I do not like their "no returns" policy for sale items though (at least here in Canada for their online site) since I would only buy their bags on sale! I have heard mixed reviews about their CS but have not had to deal with them myself.

All my Coach bags are from the Coach 1941 line and the quality is amazing (leather/suede linings, supple glovetanned leather, beautiful details) but I don't think it is fair to compare them to the MK bags I have as they also have a higher price point, though I have never paid FP. I was never interested in Coach until Coach 1941 so cannot speak to their regular line or outlet items. I have had great experiences with their customer service, and they take returns on sale items!
Click to expand...

i haven't purchases a regular MK bag in a long time. They aren't as nice as they used to be. They have definietely downgraded the leather.

I do have a couple of MK collection bags - these are very nice, but the Coach 1941 bags are equally as nice.

I had stopped purcahsing Coach over the last few years, but many of the current collections are great. And while customer service isn't as good as it used to be, it is really good.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RayKay and SEWDimples
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top