Michael Kors Quality; Michael Kors vs Coach

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

I think they're the same!! I have several from both companies. The difference comes into play with customer service. Coach is AMAZING for customer service!! I've returned 2 consecutive carly bags and currently have $400 credit just waiting for me! I also like the structure of coach bags and their compartments much better than MK.
 
I have bags from both brands and I also agree that quality is comparable. I haven't bought my MK bags from an MK store, so I am not familiar with their customer service. Coach's customer service is top notch, for sure.

I say, buy bags that you love from any brand you like. :yes:
 
I own bags from both Coach and Michael Kors. I have purchased my Coach bags only from Coach stores but, I have bought most of my Michael Kors bags from stores other than the MK store. We are fortunate enough to live in an area with access to both stores.

Now, quality wise I haven't had an issue with either brand. So, quality wise, in my opinion, they are both great. We are near an outlet with both brands also so, I visited both stores. The MK outlet had Astors (which I own 3 of) and the leather was not as soft and the bag itself was much lighter than my Astors, leading me to believe they used a lesser quality of components for the outlets. So, I passed. At the Coach outlet they had the same thing. I asked the associates and they told me Coach actually produces a line made specifically for the outlets (although they also told me they do also receive some of the full price store bags as well~ so, you have to know what you're looking for). Most of the (outlet) bags were NOT up to par with the bags (again, my opinion) from the full priced Coach stores. But, there are always excetptions. I just am not planning a trip anytime soon:)
Now, customer service...........There is a clear winner and it is Coach. The sales associates are very friendly and they really stand behind their bags for the life of the bag. The only negative I've found (and it wasn't even my situation) is a good friend of mine sent her bag for repair and Coach deemed it was unrepairable and instead of offering a choice to either return the bag to her or have Coach keep the bag and send her a coupon, they did the latter. She recieved a 40% coupon for her next purchase but, didn't get her bag back or the choice to keep the bag. The problem wasn't even that big so, she said she would have preferred to have her bag back as is. So, I feel that Coach should give the option to the owner of the bag BEFORE it is sent in for repairs. Also, you must pay the $20 shipping fees but, a small price if they are able to fix the bag. Maybe they offer a choice now, so if anyone has a different experience please let me know. Like I said, I've never had to have a bag repaired at either store.

I have only purchased boots and a bag from the actual Michael Kors store (the rest of the bags were from places like Macy's, Nordstrom~nice assoc. there and a better return/exchange policy too) and at the MK store I have had very nice sales associates as well. However, that being said the reason I prefer the dept. stores over the MK store is as mentioned by another person, is that anything on sale is a final sale. They offer a 1 year warranty on their bags and then after that you're on your own. I have bags that have sat for 3 years in my closet with the tags on so, a 1 year warranty isn't great to me. I feel like MK should up their warranty to be on the same level as Coach but, we'll have to see if that ever happens.
I will continue to purchase from both lines (and any other line) as long as I like the bags. Good luck to you and have fun w/ which ever bags you choose!
 
Hello! I have to chime in here. I just purchased a MK Astor tote and a week later the leather ripped where the strap is attached. None of my Coach bags had this problem. I say Coach is better.
 
I prefer MK over Coach because I can look at MK and always be suprised. I can always find a new design or style, but Coach (as much as I love it) has a consistent style it seems like. I always have an image in mind when I think of coach and it's usually their vintage leather styles or their more streamline 'C' pattern. I like how MK doesn't screem 'HEY I'M MICHEAL KORS' like Coach does sometimes (not all the time, yes) and I do give credit to Coach Poppy for their colorful and fun styles, but I prefer MK's 'a different bag each time' kind of feel.
 
Ok, i'm a Michael Kors fan, I own a couple of items. I recently purchased my first MK bag less than 2 months ago and just started wearing it about 3 weeks ago.

Today as i was digging in my bag when i was in my car, i felt some edges. i'm like what they heck is that. As i fumbled through my bag, i noticed a hole, a freaking whole. I'm like ok, maybe it is something small. I get home, pour out the contents of my bag, turned the liner inside out and OMG, the thread holding the bottom of the liner has unraveled and there is a huge tear! I don't know what to do. :pout: I can't put anything in the bag because it will just fall through to the bottom of the purse. I purchased the bag from Off 5th and i'm not even sure whom i need to take this issue to because this bag is useless right now!
 

Attachments

  • MK bag1.png
    MK bag1.png
    209.2 KB · Views: 6,775
I buy both too and love Hamilton! With MK I agree that the quality is consistent and you dont have to worry about the whole outlet thing! The customer service as Mandyfin said is not great. You can return a coach bag a year after you bought it( not that I would it after so long). I tried to return a MK a month after I bought it I only got store credit and now have to use it on MK!
 
I have both and I think they are comparable. I have actually had more fraying and defect issues with Coach, though. I bought a new MK wallet on Saturday and the leather is softer than any of my Coach leather bags. As someone mentioned, I do appreciate how most MK's are discreet and not flashing logos everywhere.
 
ISSUES WITH NO RETURN POLICY:
My friend bought large MK Astor bag at outlet and within a week she found bag to be super heavy and hurt her shoulders. Unfortunatley, MK outlet does not offer refunds and she did not know that before she bought it. They gave her store credit and she is very unhappy. She considered python leather but it was already having issues on the bottom. So she will try MK store and hopefully find something. She said she will not buy from MK store again.

I suggested next time to buy MK from dept store, marshalls or tjmaxx because they allow returns.
 
I own two MK bags. I purchased a small Hamilton on sale and it seems to be holding up. I purchased a large silver metallic tote with matching wallet from the outlet. Three months later the silver started wearing off both items. I was able to exchange for a leather bag with gold chains. After using the new bag a few times I noticed black flecks. I went back to the store and they wouldn't do a thing. They told me its final sale and to use the bag until it gets worse.

Coach on the other hand, has bent over backwards for me. I had a spot on my purple poppie patent leather tote. I stopped in the store to ask about cleaning it and they tried to get the stain off and were not able to. To my surprise, they gave me a brand new one! On another occasion they gave me a long leather strap for my maddison sabrina at no cost.
 
I own two MK bags. I purchased a small Hamilton on sale and it seems to be holding up. I purchased a large silver metallic tote with matching wallet from the outlet. Three months later the silver started wearing off both items. I was able to exchange for a leather bag with gold chains. After using the new bag a few times I noticed black flecks. I went back to the store and they wouldn't do a thing. They told me its final sale and to use the bag until it gets worse.

Coach on the other hand, has bent over backwards for me. I had a spot on my purple poppie patent leather tote. I stopped in the store to ask about cleaning it and they tried to get the stain off and were not able to. To my surprise, they gave me a brand new one! On another occasion they gave me a long leather strap for my maddison sabrina at no cost.

Hi, what metallic tote u bought? a gunmetal one? I am considering on buying one tote in gunmetal, for use on rainy days but now with ur post I am concerned.
 
I think it is the metallic tote. The item description say nickel. I found the bag on this website for you to see. The wallet is also there on the right side of the page.

http://myfashionny.com/shop/goods/goods_view.php?goodsno=3218
oh yes, the model is not the same, but is the same nickel color, humph, i will be thinking about buying the bag... i have the edie shoulder tote in peanut and i really like it and i have not problem at all with the bag for now.
 
Top