Not sure how much use my comment will be since I’ve never seen these particular bags in person, but! (with a grain of salt), if your decision is between these two — I say go for the second one with the more classic square shape. It does also depend on your lifestyle, of course, and I’m a huge lover of the east west shape… however, it has been quite trendy lately and many brands are turning their classic bags into EW designs. If you love the east west shape, definitely don’t let the current trendiness stop you. I ended up opting for the Lady D-Joy vs the Lady Dior pretty recently myself. But since these two bags are very similar and you’re trying to decide between them, my automatic instinct would be to go for option #2