Judging from all the reviews of the quality on
Polene's other bags, I doubt that they would make it plasticky. I personally think it looks really nice textured on the model shots. Also, I myself ordered the textured leather in black so will be able to share when it arrives.

I noticed that most people on this forum bought the smooth leather, so haven't seen any "real" pictures of what the textured looks like.
The smooth is sooooo pretty, I might have to buy a second bag with it if/when it comes back in stock. This depends if the smooth leather is easy to scratch. I bought the textured one because I was looking for an everyday bag that I could bring traveling, running errands, going out to bars, potentially going clubbing with it, etc, hanging out with my small dog, without having to worry about any scratches accumulating.