Please help me decide. Blue Nile studs v old studs...pics

much prefer the 4 prong setting of the old ones. also, i highly recommend pearl earrings instead...i wear mine almost every single day!
 
Great studs! I think I would just keep the old pair, since they look very similar to me (though the Blue Nile look just a smidge more sparkly).
If you want slightly more coverage, I would consider selling the old pair and compounding your funds to buy a larger pair of studs from Blue Nile, good color and excellent cut. If you don't really care about the size, just keep your old pair and enjoy! They're beautiful!