I completely understand. I have 5 duffes, 2 isabelles, 2 courtenays, 2 carry all, 3 mini duffes, and 4 pennies. I also have a hard time returning them but sometimes I will exchange to other items.
Ugh- this is me, too! I'm a "style hoarder"- when I find the style that works for me I get it in several colors and then I never know which one to carry!
Add me to that number! I have 6 Candaces, 4 East West Gallery Totes, 2 Mollys and more multiples I can't remember at the moment.
I'm the same way! I have tunnel vision when it comes to my bags. We will not talk about how many Lindseys, Sophias, and Sabrinas I own.