Opinion Engagement Ring
- Thread starter marialc121
- Start date
i like the centre stone of the 1st one...
but the band of the second ring....
can you combine? eehhehehheee
but the band of the second ring....
can you combine? eehhehehheee
IMHO, I think it is also important for you to think about center stone size. What size center stone were you looking to obtain? The first one can lend itself easier to a 1/2- 1 carat, because rounds show larger than emerald cuts. So, if you want a bigger presence for a smaller center stone, then go for #1. If you are going for larger than 1 carat, then either stone would be lovely. Congrats on your engagement, btw.
We are trying to decide between a 1.5 or 2 carat depending on which shape. Since the round shape is more expensive, we can only go to a 1.5 but with the emerald, we may be able to go with the 2. In any case, I appreciate you guys for your advice. This has been great help for me. 
I don't know about VCA, but with Cartier/Tiffany/HW, the price is more than $50,000, they might have room for negotiation. If around $100,000, they will have room for discount.
VCA and Cartier are affilated companies, so perhaps?
I know for a fact that Cartier has discounted. My fiance's parents are very good Cartier customers and he has told me that they've gotten a discount. I don't know the specifics, but I know that there is room to wiggle on certain pieces (I'm sure not on love bracelets since they're in high demand). They usually buy watches/evening jewelry... So maybe on a higher carat cocktail-ish ring, they will negotiate?
I agree, but it's hard for me to choose since one has the "bling" factor and the other one is more simple. 