If you are OCD and need your things to stay pristine. then don’t get anything in Barenia. It will show every mark and scratch. It will absorb oil from your hands and darken. And then, it will eventually all blend into a wonderful patina.
People either love Barenia with all the passion in their hearts, or it’s just not for them. There doesn’t seem to be a middle ground on this leather.
One thing Barenia is NOT is fragile. I have a fully-patina’d, 20 year old Barenia Kelly and I swear that thing is indestructible. It’s my favorite bag and I think it’s amazingly beautiful, but it will never look new.
My advice is to do an image search for Barenia and get a good look at how it ages. If it appeals to you, definitely get that Barenia Bastia. Just beware, using it will make you want more things in this leather!