I think it depends on whether the Roxy is very desirable, in otherwise perfect condition and backed up by a convincing receipt. I would certainly pay you much less for a bag that I would have to go to the trouble to repair unless it was a very starry one.
Thought i had posted it already but its not showing up for me sorry for posting twice
All points taken but not sure if I can be bothered to get it repaired may just list it and take a large hit on it but it is in vgc apart from the stud
better say no more as don't want to get into trouble Thanks for your thoughts