Good. Those emotional and poisonous reviews as well as those simply shouting amazing can be left out. It is like the Olympics diving rating system - filter out the lowest and highest rating
Well, I don't know... I'm obviously happier for good than bad reviews, since I don't think this movie is gonna be the typical movie of the year. We already know it's a kind of low budget movie made out of a very good book which people can enjoy or not. It's not about social issues, it's about personal issues, so it's easy to like it a lot or don't like it at all.
I agree with Michael and Alicia the purpose of the movie is to lead the audience to a kind of crossroads, to generate a discussion... I saw many people writing reviews saying they needed to take some days to think about the events happened in the story and what would they would have done in the character's shoes.. Well, this means the movie gives rise to discussions -as the book did and keeps doing- and this is better than every positive/negative review IMO. Reviews are tastes, saying a movie made you think about life etc it's a more universal thing.