While a big part of the dislike of AV has to do with her own words & personality/appearance obviously, I think another huge turn off is her PR & fans. Her PR is not at all sophisticated and her fans can be OTT & ridiculous. It's like Tom Hiddleston for me; I could maybe like him, but he's so try hard and his fans are so, so ridiculous that I just can't.
With alicia, you have this big PR push of her as It Girl, to which people will naturally push back against because they don't like being told who to like (that's why JLaw was successful, because she never really had that kind of concerted It Girl campaign, at least not until she was actually "It" - and then she started getting backlash). You saw the push back with alicia right away, with people saying "I don't get the hype, she's bland and boring." But then her fans (or PR, they're interchangeable at this point) went all over proclaiming "but you are WRONG! She's a special sparkling snowflake, how dare you say such vile things about her! Jealous!" And this was actually before any "vile" things had even been said about her, because not getting someones hype is not "vile". So people push back against that, and it has just snowballed from there. Add in the unflattering/unfavorable press (and I include the overly-gushingly positive pieces too, because to most people that will read as a fake PR plant, whether it is or not), and it adds up to an overall bad impression left on those who were on the fence about her. Her PR sucks and her fans only make it worse.
As for the "vile" Weinstein rumors, many actresses have these kinds of rumors, from Blake Lively to Gwenyth Paltrow to JLaw to Jessica Chastain (although my fave Chastain explanation for her rise out of nowhere is that she is the illegitimate child of Ron Howard! Lol). But some AV fans go so hard about this as if she's the only actress ever gossiped about in this way, it comes off sounding like they "doth protest too much", which just adds to people's convictions. That NY Times reporter comparing her to Blake Lively didn't help, because it was such a random comparison. When I saw that picture of alicia beaming up at Harvey, it made me wonder if that was why the reporter chose that particular comparison, because if you wanna talk about vicious, check out the Lively rumors. But even without that, the HW rumors were inevitable, it happens to everyone who comes out of nowhere hailed as an It girl. Welcome to Hollywood!
With alicia, you have this big PR push of her as It Girl, to which people will naturally push back against because they don't like being told who to like (that's why JLaw was successful, because she never really had that kind of concerted It Girl campaign, at least not until she was actually "It" - and then she started getting backlash). You saw the push back with alicia right away, with people saying "I don't get the hype, she's bland and boring." But then her fans (or PR, they're interchangeable at this point) went all over proclaiming "but you are WRONG! She's a special sparkling snowflake, how dare you say such vile things about her! Jealous!" And this was actually before any "vile" things had even been said about her, because not getting someones hype is not "vile". So people push back against that, and it has just snowballed from there. Add in the unflattering/unfavorable press (and I include the overly-gushingly positive pieces too, because to most people that will read as a fake PR plant, whether it is or not), and it adds up to an overall bad impression left on those who were on the fence about her. Her PR sucks and her fans only make it worse.
As for the "vile" Weinstein rumors, many actresses have these kinds of rumors, from Blake Lively to Gwenyth Paltrow to JLaw to Jessica Chastain (although my fave Chastain explanation for her rise out of nowhere is that she is the illegitimate child of Ron Howard! Lol). But some AV fans go so hard about this as if she's the only actress ever gossiped about in this way, it comes off sounding like they "doth protest too much", which just adds to people's convictions. That NY Times reporter comparing her to Blake Lively didn't help, because it was such a random comparison. When I saw that picture of alicia beaming up at Harvey, it made me wonder if that was why the reporter chose that particular comparison, because if you wanna talk about vicious, check out the Lively rumors. But even without that, the HW rumors were inevitable, it happens to everyone who comes out of nowhere hailed as an It girl. Welcome to Hollywood!