Kristin. Love the external pocket! Plus, the Peyton leather is kinda thin and the bag looked lumpy when I tried it out with my stuff inside. I haven't tried my stuff inside a Kristin hobo but the leather feels thicker to me than on the Peyton. I do have a Kristin wristlet and it doesn't look lumpy when I stuff it to the gills. Oh, and I also like the Kristin's crossbody option which the Peyton shoulder bag does not have. HTH!