Hey, so I got both of the
amazon options. the $20 insert converter and the $27 plastic sleeve and insert set. I have 2 large kirigami pochettes that I use them with, 1 leather and 1 monogram. I got the insert converter summer of last year, and I just got the plastic sleeve last week. I hope my review below will help ^^
First off, I always feel super creative and chic wearing my kirigami as a crossbody ^^ . however it does have some ( maybe pretty major ) flaws. The d-ring on the insert does extend out very far, so the clasp on the chain is always digging into the corner of the flaps and in danger of falling off the D-ring. It happened to me once at a restaurant, I just made like I meant to take off my purse to pay ( but it would be weird if it happened while on public transit....) I had been using the insert converter for 3-4 months when I noticed that the clasp on the chain was rubbing away the waxed edge on the flap ( so right were the clasp for the chain and the d-ring on the insert meet, that area on the kirigami is a bit warped and the edging is rubbed off ) the insert itself isn't doing anything. I still use it (b/x the damage is done ) and I like the look. The felt insert has never " slipped out of my kirigami, it fits well and I can organize / fit more into the pochette when I use the insert vs when I don't
The $27 set is pretty worth it, I think there was a price decrease since last year. Set includes 1 plastic sleeve ( which has a 'phone pocket' in the back), 1 felt insert, 2 chains ( a long metal chain and a short plastic one ) and a "twilly" type scarf. This set is pretty new for me but already I can tell there Might be an issue moving forwards. First, the plastic sleeve for the set is very fitted so there may be a bit of resistance getting it into the sleeve ( but this means it won't randomly slip out on you ). and with that is the fear of tearing/ warping your kirigama as you pull you kirigami out of the sleeve. The material is good its a thick clear plastic, and it's held into its shape using brass/ gold snaps (so I'm not worried about it's construction ). I haven't used it in the summer enviroment, so I question if the plastic will fuse ( I hope it wont!!). Second the screw which holds the drings for pouch are pretty abrasive and I'm just always afraid that this is the time the screw will make a mark on my pouchette. The felt insert is pretty nifty, the design is different than the photos shown on the page, it does NOT have the metal bits at the top, so it is ONLY and insert. Its does have 2 small pockets in the back, a large compartment and a short front compartment. I have decided to keep the set, mostly because the plastic sleeve ( with a bit of modifications ) will also fit the "first generation " rivet envelope pochette ( which I think launched the kirigami line ?)