Hi Ladies,
I am new here but have collected JC charms for awhile.
I have a question for you...I just bought the JC Charm Catcher seen HERE as I wanted a new way to wear them.
Most of my charms are from 2006 and none of clasps fit over the catcher. Has anyone else had that problem?
Or do you think this catcher is a fake? It looks legit to me.
It looks legit to me, since I have that same charm catcher. katierose has a good point about it being a stock photo, though.
As for the clasps being too small for it, I have only run into that issue with the pave pumpkin which is a newer charm from 2011. Something about the lever is different and it will NOT fit on that charm catcher nor most of my purses that have ring hardware.
Wish I'd noticed it sooner so I could have returned it to JC for a different one! I bought it after Halloween was over, though, and didn't really put it into use until the next year. By then it was too late to get a replacement. Not too much of a tragedy though, since I have other catchers to wear it with. The purse thing was the most annoying.

Last edited: