^ I was debating the Cleaves too and went back and forth between yes and no. Then when I thought I'd order them to try them on Matches was sold out and now I'm again not sure about them. We have harsh winters here too and I just don't think I could wear the boots and be comfortable (warm) for the most part of winter. They don't have any kind of a lining and at least with Dickers my toes get cold pretty easily.
And I don't even usually go for knee-high boots but there is just something about those Cleaves...
And I don't even usually go for knee-high boots but there is just something about those Cleaves...