Did you purchase in store or was it shipped to you? I just bought the exact same wallet in Scarlet. I went into the store but they did not have any available to purchase in store. They had it in Noir and i looked at those in store. I was not impressed. First for a $900 wallet they just had them thrown inside a drawer on top of each other. Honestly that really rubbed me the wrong way. If I'm spending close to $1000 on a wallet I'm expecting it to be kept neatly put away maybe even with the dust cover to protect it but that was not the case. They were mixed in with other wallets. The first one the SA showed me i noticed it had scratches on the front button. I asked to see another and the second one she showed me was better but still looked a bit tarnished and not all shiny and new how i'm expecting it to look. Since they didn't have the color i wanted i asked them to order it. I received it on Valentines day. I love it but i did notice that the front button was not the shiny gold i was expecting, its not matte but its not as shiny as the zipper pull. Also the front button has minor scratches on it. Other then that everything else looks fine. I say if it bothers you exchange it. I'm keeping mine because i'm in love with the color and the wallet itself and i know eventually the front button is going to get scratched up anyways.