Thank you for your input! I called LV and they were able to offer an exchange. Once they receive my return, they will then begin the process of fulfilling the exchange order. I was surprised they were even able to offer an exchange with it being a HTF item.
I sent them photos of the bag so that they didn't think it was me who had used it and then returned it. I do agree that this may have been a return, especially since it came from the Piscataway, NJ warehouse instead of Secaucus. I know with COVID they may be sending new items from Piscataway, but in my personal experience the only two online orders I've had issues with have come from this warehouse.
Fingers crossed that the next one is perfect!