I didn't think it felt scratchy when I tried them on in the store. They have some that just have the weaving on the edges. Many are made of napa so they are soft. The problem I'm finding with looking at pre-loved is that they are either super big or small. Half of the ones listed are vintage textured leather that I don't like at all. I figure if I'm spending that much, it has to be the perfect color, shape and size. I found one that is a great price, is a style I could live with, but is black, so I'm wavering. On the one hand, it would be a way to try it out for not too much money, but on the other hand, it is black and the seller doesn't take returns.