I honestly love the Watermelon on you. It's the perfect pop of color with what you're wearing in this picture. If it was on a different bag style, I don't think I'd be so drawn to it but it's perfect on the Dufflette. I'm so in love with your previous pics of this color that I returned the Denim and I'm patiently waiting for another sale to grab this one. My son liked it best when I tried them on but I was so caught up in potentially missing the blue that I just got it instead. It's a beautiful blue but...when I received the black, I cut the tags immediately but with Denim I didn't...I should've known then. I think the Saddle would be just as pretty on you. It just really depends on if you'll feel comfortable and reach for the Watermelon as much. I'd go with the color that you'll want to use more. And I would most definitely exchange for a new one. It's your new bag and you should be completely happy with it. Looks awesome on you! Not too bright at all.
Hi
TMWM!! Thanks for your kind feedback! I think I really like the Denim too! Oh boy, I am in trouble. I went back to the beginning of the thread and drooled over your amazing pics and mod shots. The black looks ah-mazing on you too! Oh man, these Dufflettes are just too adorable. I have never done this with any bag before but I think I may eventually end up with more than one color!
You can bust on in anytime with beautiful pictures.

The more we have is just the more it's going to help someone who is trying to decide. If you start a clubhouse, I'll join!
You're the trailblazer and (enabler :giggles

so you start the Clubhouse and I will definitely follow............still undecided being the procrastinator that I am....)
Love this POP of color!!! Especially fun if you tend to go with neutrals. I say go for it!!
Thank you so much
BeachBagGal - it's a lovely POP as you say.....I am just a little hesistant and keep wondering why I can't commit 100% (as much as I love it).
Thanks, it's that for a reason lol(my username)
If you feel uncomfortable with the color and would feel the saddle would serve you better than go that route, you want to enjoy the bag not always be questioning the color.
That all said, the WM suits this bag and is lovely! but brighter colored bags are not for everyone... the most color i tend to here are reds... i have a Peyton satchel in a patent berry, to me that is colorful lol
Thanks
HesitantShopper - you knocked the nail right on the head (as did TMWM when she said I should go with the color I would reach for more)......I feel like Saddle would be more 'neutral' for me. I don't tend to change out my bags often (hate to admit it but I am really a one-bag girl and stick with a bag for a long time - please don't hurt me all you bag-fashionistas

:lolots

.
So my initial pick off the bat was the Saddle, when I went into Macy's to check them out IRL I sent hubby a pic of Saddle and he saw the WM in the background and he was like what about the orange one? So hence the dilemma began. Going back through this thread has been helpful, I think it was Aubergined who so kindly did a side-by-side comparison of her Carnelian Legacy Duffle vs WM Dufflette. Looking more closely now, and I realize it is a very subtle difference - but I am leaning towards the Carnelian shade more. I feel like such a doofus for getting so worked up over the color, but something inside me tells me that as much as I love the WM - the Saddle would be more versatile for me. I am very much a 'grab and go gal' and don't like changing out bags. I feel foolish for saying 'WM it is earlier in this thread' only to wake up yesterday and today questioning myself. Ai yi yi - third world problems. :shame:. Part of my problem is that I am pretty careful about spending and need to make sure I make the right decision.
I think I will carefully unpackage and load up Saddle and see how it grabs me. Hubby is going to

at me, as he really likes WM, and always maintains that I do the opposite of what he says. Thank you for letting me ponder here as I would surely drive him mad with all my back and forth!
Thanks for everyone's opinions - please don't think I am trying to be difficult......I hope some of you would understand having being torn between colors yourself!
On a different note, there are two things I would do to improve this already fabulous bag - first would be to change the name - Dufflette - sounds a bit odd to me (-ette makes it sound like a small bag which it is not) and second, if it had an outside, back zippered pocket this bag would be perfection! Lol.
Thanks for listening and kudos if you've made it this far through my ramblings!

(apologies for the mega-thread but I finally figured out how to work multiquote!)