I need advice!!

The artsy reminds me more of a tote, like you would use to go to the beach or day trip. The galliera seems more like a handbag. The artsy is very casual looking and very, very roomy. I don't care for the handle on the artsy.
 
Galliera - it's a beautiful hobo bag! To me, Artsy is a bit "neither here nor there"...not feeling for it due to the short/hard handle, wide base and overall shape.