I returned a walnut maggie that came from jax with two deep scratches on it and the sa put as reason for return was that I didn't like that style. I didn't realize that she put that on the receipt until I got home. so that makes me look bad when it was really not my fault for the return.
I've also returned some defective items that had to be damaged out and the SAs listed "changed mind" on my retun receipts as well.
You know, thinking more about it, I think most stores do this! You can return without receipt, but if you start doing it more than a few times they can and will decline the return!
I think the policy to allow a return (which really, is just store credit I think?) without a receipt is just so that a frequent buyer who accidentally loses the odd receipt is not stuck with a purse. Though, I wonder if it would be easier if they didn't promote this though, and let it go on a case by case basis?