I Hope I Don't Sound Weird or Creepy...

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

I would agree with everyone else not to bring it up or wear them. He probably has forgotten he even has them, and you dont want to stir up old memories. Another woman wore that ring as a symbol of her love for this man for 20 years- I almost think it would be disrespectful to what they had together to wear the ring, although I know your intentions are nothing but good!
 
Hmmmm. I don't know any of the details of your fiance's break-up with his first wife so I couldn't possibly comment as to the sentimental value of the rings (if any). Saving the rings for his son is a nice gesture but he may not want "bad luck" jewelry either, KWIM? having the stone reset is another possibility.

I still have my engagement and wedding rings from my first marriage, and my husband has the diamond and wedding rings he gave his first wife. (Their divorce was acrimonious, she intitiated it, and in anger he took the rings.) To me, it's all just jewelry, but I'm not emotional about things like that and my husband frankly dislikes his first wife too much to get misty-eyed about their history together. I would never wear the actual ring he gave her but I wouldn't have a problem having the stone reset and wearing it.
 
Sure, you CAN wear someone else's ring, but considering the symbolism behind e-rings and wedding bands, i wouldnt ... i look at my e-ring and i dont even feel like im looking at a diamond ... i feel like im looking at him ... that prob doesnt make sense ...

im with the other girls - get a fabulous RHR for christmas :kiss:

I feel the same way, basically, so I can totally understand your POV with this. The item reminds me so much of the person that he is; it ceases to be "just a ring."
 
Hmmmm. I don't know any of the details of your fiance's break-up with his first wife so I couldn't possibly comment as to the sentimental value of the rings (if any). Saving the rings for his son is a nice gesture but he may not want "bad luck" jewelry either, KWIM? having the stone reset is another possibility.

I still have my engagement and wedding rings from my first marriage, and my husband has the diamond and wedding rings he gave his first wife. (Their divorce was acrimonious, she intitiated it, and in anger he took the rings.) To me, it's all just jewelry, but I'm not emotional about things like that and my husband frankly dislikes his first wife too much to get misty-eyed about their history together. I would never wear the actual ring he gave her but I wouldn't have a problem having the stone reset and wearing it.

My BF dislikes his ex a whole hell of a lot too...but I know that even though he hasn't LIKED her for years, he probably has loved her even if only because she is the mother of his son. He's never told me that he regretted their breakup in any way, so I, too, am not sure if he has a lot of sentimental attachment to the rings. I just find it all so interesting, though!

Her energy is in that ring and whatever energy came from that marriage. You do not want any part of that.

Good point.

I would agree with everyone else not to bring it up or wear them. He probably has forgotten he even has them, and you dont want to stir up old memories. Another woman wore that ring as a symbol of her love for this man for 20 years- I almost think it would be disrespectful to what they had together to wear the ring, although I know your intentions are nothing but good!

Yes, and wow...to me, that is SUCH a long time. It's about two-thirds of the time I've been alive. But you're right, through some of that 20 year period, I'm sure she loved him to pieces.

to tell you the truth i would ask why he still had it.. because it would bug me to know..

I wonder this, too...it doesn't annoy me or piss me off, but...again it just seems like something she would have kept. Esp. since HE was the one that filed.

Tiffany's owwwww:faint:, it's beautiful! If you love it, go see it for yourself irl one day and if you still love it, then get it for yourself. It would make a beautiful gift for yourself.

So, i have a question, i don't know if anyone has asked you this or if you have answered, does he know that you know about the rings? I'm just wondering.[/quote]

I don't think he knows that I've seen them or been to their "hiding place." We were watching TV together once, and this cash-for-gold commercial came on, and I said something like, "Hey, scrap gold. You can sell you old wedding rings!" He didn't even react to that statement. I never told him that I saw them, but maybe he figured that I was just assuming he still had them.

No...I have worn my late MIL's rings, but I would not want to wear anything that was purchased by my husband for another woman.

:smile1: I can certainly understand that. It seems to be a common sentiment. If he had tried to pass off her ring as my engagement ring, I would have had issues, but since I already have a ring that serves the same purpose as her old one, I guess I don't see it as a big deal.

No. I would think it would remind him of her whenever he sees them on your hand. Maybe he might go for melting it down and making another item or just taking the stones and setting them in something different. Then he probably wouldn't know the difference.

That is another idea...but...for some reason, I'd kind of like to leave the ring as is. I don't know...maybe I should just point-blank ask him about it...or maybe I shouldn't.

I almost had my chance two nights ago, and I KICK myself because I didn't!

We were at margarita night, getting slowly buzzed. I spotted my cousin and her best friend, a lady who is a friend of the family. They're both around my BF's age, which is about 15 to 20 years older than me (I don't know their exact ages). My cousin's girlfriend hadn't really talked to me since I got engaged, but I know that she's SEEN me, because she was at the family reunion. Anyway, I walk over there to speak and hang out, and my cousin is all, "You know, ___________ is engaged!" So the friend was like, "Oh?" And then she GRABS my hand and looks at my ring. I have no clue why women do that. And she just smiled a little.

When I went back to sit with the BF, I kind of complained that I don't know why when you get engaged or announce your engagement, the first thing other women want to do is look at the ring! So we talked about engagement rings for a minute or so and I kept telling myself, "Bring up the ring. Bring up the ring!" I was gonna say something like, "When you got engaged to ______________ was it the same way? Oh? So, what are you going to do with her old engagment ring and wedding band?" It would have been such a good segue, but I couldn't bring myself to have that discussion.

:shrugs:
 
I would just ask him - I am sure he wouldn't mind.

He may like to offer them back to the mother of his children as a "gift" as they were hers (she may like to make a divorce ring out of it - a friend of mine had one made for her middle finger :roflmfao:), he might like to give them to his children. My husband still had his old wedding band when we got married. He put in my "pile of broken bits of gold jewellery, odd earrings etc" and next time I have something made it will melted down and added it to that.

I don't believe I could wear someone elses wedding set - however I could wear jewellery made out of them. I tend to believe it has been melted down any sentimentality would of melted away as well!
 
I wouldn't....i agree with others, the ring is "memory" of those years belonged to him and someone else. Personally i don't even like the idea that hes kept the ring. I one time found my bf and his ex's matching rings with their names engraved inside, and i felt livid and frustrated.....


I agree, and that's the resaon why I wouldn't..
 
I wouldn't have a problem wearing someone else's rings, to me they are just possessions and it can be cool to wear something with its own history. I wouldn't want it as my primary ring, but just once in awhile it would be okay. But if he's keeping them as a way to hold onto an ex, it would probably be better to sell them or melt them down or give them to the son if keeping them is preventing him from letting go of the past. It just depends what the rings mean to you and him.
 
I wouldn't. It's tempting in a way to want to have part of him from his younger years, but those younger years belonged to him and someone else. Whatever happened with them later I would respect that, and leave alone all personal property he gave to her during that time (even if he has the rings now).

I personally think that it would be a better idea to keep the rings safe, and when the time comes for his son to think about marriage pass them on to him to do what he likes with them.
I absolutely agree. I would wait and give him a chance to chose a right ring for me (a right hand ring this time) and would never like to wear something that somebody else got. This ring probably means a lot of memories to him and it would be better if it stayed that way. Probably he intends to give it to his kids or something. Besides, think about the future you two have together and how many jewelry you can get that will mean and remind you a lot of your life as a couple and leave his past behind you,
 
I can't really add anything worthwhile to what you wonderful ladies have already said, but your post did remind me of a bit from a Grey's Anatomy episode... :)

Addison (holding up her wedding rings): What do I do with these? Hock 'em, keep 'em...
Callie: My mom said divorce wedding rings are bad juju.
Addison: Your mom does juju?
Callie: She does.
Addison: So... well, what would your mom do?
Callie: Burn 'em. Bury 'em.
Addison: Do you want 'em?
Callie (laughing): I want some rings, just not bad juju rings. Then again, my mom's kinda insane.
Bailey: Hey, don't talk smack about your mom.
 
Top