How to find a perfect GIA diamond? Help needed

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

Wait....why not THAT diamond exactly? Is it sold? If you're giving them a range, you don't want one that deep.

AME,
I discussed with my SO, and I think that one is over our budget.
That jeweler found one diamond within the spec, it is currently in oversea. would you please check it for me? This one is about $5350, is this a reasonable price? Thanks!
 

Attachments

  • 1381317783162.jpg
    1381317783162.jpg
    141.1 KB · Views: 274
Dear Phoebe,
To find a perfect diamond, I think you need to define first what is perfect for you, which will also depend on what your priorities are, which may differ from mine and or others in this forum.

For example, for me:
1. My first priority was the price.
2. My second priority was the cut. Combination of crown & pavilion angles, etc.
3. Third priority was the combination of color and clarity. I didn't want to go lower than I, preferably F-H color, and I didn't want a clarity lower then VS.
4. The setting was my last priority as I thought and still think a well cut diamond stands out even in a very simple setting. So, I took a standard setting, cheaper therefore more bucks for the stone.

Once my priorities set, than I search the stone from reputable vendors. Not sure if I could mention vendors, but I purchased from Crafted by Infinity, Whiteflash and Good Old Gold and I'm super happy with them all. Moderator please remove the vendor names if it's against the forum policy.

How did I know my priorities (re. cut, color, HCA,Asset, Arrow, etc...) once the budget was fixed? I spent a lot of time, learning about the cut quality on the pricescope forum. There are plenty of resources there and I learned a lot lurking on various forum discussions.
For the color preference, I think you need to see and try it yourself comparing how different colors match your skin tone and please your visual preferences (I tried down to wellcut M color). This process seeing and comparing myself while I educating myself was really valuable for me (before I educated myself , I thought the perfect diamonds should be 3 ex GIA, F color maxi with preference D, and VVS clarity. See how much I changed)

I'm sorry if my post doesn't really answer your question. I hope it could help nonetheless.n

Wow kimpossible...I set the same 4 rules for myself although GHI were my color ranges. Great advice! :smile1:
 
AME,
I discussed with my SO, and I think that one is over our budget.
That jeweler found one diamond within the spec, it is currently in oversea. would you please check it for me? This one is about $5350, is this a reasonable price? Thanks!

The proportions are great, angularly, I don't LOVE the girdle thickness, because it takes a tiny bit from the diameter, but it should perform very well.

Pricewise, that's a little high assuming that's the price in USD. In the US, that diamond would run you between $4,000 and $4,500, perhaps for a branded stone, a little higher. If they're charging you that price including the costs to bring it in, that would be more reasonable. However, you being overseas, that's where you're kind of stuck. Goods like this cost more overseas so it's kind of hard to compare the prices and say what's fair and what's not.
 
Last edited:
The proportions are great, angularly, I don't LOVE the girdle thickness, because it takes a tiny bit from the diameter, but it should perform very well.

Pricewise, that's a little high assuming that's the price in USD. In the US, that diamond would run you between $4,000 and $4,500, perhaps for a branded stone, a little higher. If they're charging you that price including the costs to bring it in, that would be more reasonable. However, you being overseas, that's where you're kind of stuck. Goods like this cost more overseas so it's kind of hard to compare the prices and say what's fair and what's not.

Thanks so much. :D
 
I think clarity and color are the most important thing to start with. Only then think about the size-prize related numbers. It's better to have smaller stone, but with better clarity and preferred color. It is also wise in terms of investment. Also, check for fluorescence under UV. I personally don't like it, and it may be a sign the stone is synthetic.
 
That statement is completely inaccurate. A diamond containing fluorescence does not indicate a stone is synthetic. Fluorescence in diamonds is a naturally occurring trait, and for many people, it is something they seek out. It also allows people to buy a slightly larger stone than they might otherwise be able to because they can go down a color grade or two without experiencing the additional warmth that sometimes occurs due to the fluorescence offsetting the appearance of that warmth.

To explain why your specific point about synthetics is not accurate: actual synthetics are not diamonds in chemical composition, and they typically don't fluoresce, but a lab grown diamond which is actually a real diamond, can. There are specific lab grown diamonds that will show fluorescence, but those will test as such because their thermoconductivity is different, and a diamond tester can usually identify that, and those stones are indicated as lab-created on the grading report, and the color they fluoresce will vary based on the way they're made.

And also, diamonds are not a sound investment, high color and clarity or not. Diamonds and most gemstones don't retain their value and won't typically sell for even close to what was paid on the secondary market unless there's some sort of provenance, i.e. a celebrity with a story owned it, royalty, etc. While all traits are figured carefully to sale a value, the cut quality and sometimes even size typically outranks color or clarity when valuation is set for resale, as a poorly cut D FL will not fetch as much as a well cut D FL will.
 
Top