I had the goyard too and sold it after a month. The handles were so stiff and uncomfortable. The attached pouch was so small it barely fit anything. So it really felt like my bag was wide open and unsecured.I definitely feel the Goyard is more durable. I can treat it like the bag is supposed to be used (throwing a bunch of random things in it) and there is no surface wear or interior wear. With my neverfulls I feel like they are more delicate and I have to be more cautious - they're more prone to scuffs on the exterior and stains on patina.
I recently got the neverfull and I'm very surprised to find that I like it. The handles are comfortable and stay on my shoulder. I can keep my valuables in the inner zip compartment and in the pouch and that makes the bag work for me even though it open top.
Strange how different things work for different folks!