I’m baaack!
Okay, I am deciding between something in Evercolor (in a color I love), Fjord (in a color I like a lot), and a brown Vibrato (which I am intrigued by).
Thoughts?
Agree with
@maxroxxherhandbags, Fjord is fabulous, thick and chewy, and yes, full of character! It is heavy though, so if it's a large bag that you plan to load up I would keep that in mind. (I have a Fjord Plume 28.)
I don't own anything in Evercolor or Vibrato, but also agree that Vibrato is beautiful. As I understand it, it did come with an eraser sort of thing to be used to clean minor spots. I also understand that Vibrato can't be serviced by Hermes. I think of Vibrato as more of a collector's piece rather than a first bag staple, but if it were a toss off in your budget and not some sort of reach, and you LOVED it, there are some lovely pieces out there in resale land.
Are these choices all the same style of bags or are you considering a few different options? Hand carry, shoulder carry and crossbody styles might change your view on the leather choice, and your intended use for the bag may as well. I don't think I'd go for a Fjord Birkin for example; it's too heavy to all day, and because Fjord is such a sturdy leather, it would be a Birkin I'd want to carry often and throw around, and then by the afternoon I'd be very, very, sorry. I'm certain Evercolor is much lighter but I'm not familiar with its attributes to opine on whether that's a good or bad idea, or even available for a Birkin (scratches? dents? rubbing?).
You might try setting up a chart of the bags you're thinking about, sort of a matrix, and by adding in the pros and cons, see what that might reveal. It's hard if you have all of the variables in play as opposed to having decided that your first bag will be X style, and then it's a question of what leathers suit that style best for you and what colors best suit your wardrobe, all of course within your budget parameters. HTH!
ETA Just saw
@Helventara's comments and am glad to hear that Vibrato holds up well to regular usage!