I saw the punch on the coach site but I never think those pix are very accurate. Has anyone seen the punch in real life?
most coach stores should carry the signature stripe hat in punch, it's backstocked probably, so you can ask them to show you, it should match the bag exactly.
i prefer the parchment and blue the best. they were the best sellers too, so thats a bit tough to get your hands on.
the mahogony is nice too for everyday.
the gold is gorgeous.
and the white khaki looks drool worthy.
sorry! i don't think i could be much of a help. if i didn't have a thing against signature (personal preference) i wouldn't be able to decide either!!!