Help me choose a new bag..

[F10909]

OK
So I am looking for a new bag for 2017.

I tend to like buttery soft leather and slouchy contours but will consider some bags like the Swagger. I need something in a neutral color and compatible with just about all occasions. Right now here are my contenders.

Coach

Edie 31
Lexy
Phoebe
Swagger 31 (Large Satchel)
Swagger 27 (Medium Satchel)

I am also considering a Kate Spade Cobble Hill option and have rummaged through eBay looking at older products from Coach that are nwt or nwot.

 

[Nymeria1]

I vote for the Phoebe, one of Coach's most beautiful bags. The leather is buttery, soft, and luscious! I own five Phoebes, three large and two "regular" ones. If you want gorgeous leather, Phoebe is it!!

 

[Mortuary Maven]

I'm falling more and more in love with my Swagger 27. It's the burnished glovetanned leather one in surplus, which is my first bag with color, and it's striking but neutral enough to go with pretty much everything in my wardrobe. The leather is really soft and lovely to the touch. Just today I was marveling (internally) at how nice the leather on the handles felt in my hand even though they're structured.