Oh cute website! I went with the Tiffany's bank yesterday b/c it was quick and cute, but I'm definitely saving your website for the future. One of my friends just annouced this weekend that she and her husband are trying to have a baby so looks like I'll be buying more baby gifts in the future!
A dear young friend of mine will be having her first baby towards the end of this year. I might give her a pair of adorable handmade shoes by BumbleBeeDesigns:
This "Honey buns all natural diaper salve" has had some excellent feedback - it's meant for preventing and treating mild diaper rash and irritation but has also been used on dry adult skin.
For the offspring of a firefighter, how about this? This pair of firefighter boots is meant for a 6-9 month old baby but kraftyladykreations will do custom work: