Wow. A line like that is totally devastating, especially when the rest of the Rose is so gorgeous and shiny. I purchased my Rose Spring Street used several months ago, and it has a slight yellow hue to it, but even and all over. I use it a lot. The silver Spring Street I purchased looks even better than the Rose (IMO), very shiny and no discoloration. Let's just hope that it's true the new Vernis technology is getting better. My SA just told me the same thing this week. That older colors are flatter and newer technology has improved Vernis. Oh man, given all my vernis, not sure how to deal with this.. except use them and love them no matter what... I'm so sorry, the line totally sucks....