Have an opportunity to trade black m/c wapity for m/c mini sac hl~ should I?

[HuntJumpSC]

I happened across an a local ad for a black multicolor mini sac hl, it is authentic and I have been in contact with the owner, who may consider a trade on my black Wapity. She's asking $300 for hers, and I paid $250 for mine. She's also willing to entertain an offer as long as it's reasonable. The bag is in great shape and comes with the dustbag.
I've used my Wapity for holding my cell phone and a couple of other small items. Should I do it?

 

[monokuro]

If it were me.. I would.. xD

I love the mini sac HL!

 

[SaraDK]

I prefer the Wapity over mini sac HL..
I think its to small for adults.. Sorry if I'm offending anyone.. Just my opinion..

 

[GabLVoesvuitton]

yes, you should do it! i've have my mini hl in white mc since i was 12-i'm 18 now-& i still use it!!

 

[bernz84]

I like the mini sac better because it's bigger than the wapity (and it actually holds more than a pochette accessoires). I'd go for it.

 

[LxTxNx]

Wapity!

 

[HuntJumpSC]

Thanks guys! I'm leaning towards doing the swap, if she accepts my offer. It might be a cute go-to bag for quick runs to the store or to carry when going out. My wapity is perfect for my cell phone, but I can always toss it somewhere else easy enough.

 

[HuntJumpSC]

I just heard back from her, and she would do the swap for the Wapity and $150. Would that be fair? The sac hl is in great used condition.

 

[bernz84]

Eh, I don't know...how abused is your wapity (is the pattern faded? Is the leather dark)? And how nice-looking is the HL (leather, interior, etc)? I've seen used MC Mini Sacs go for $300-350 at most and MC wapities go for $200-$300 on ebay. I think I would pass this trade, but that's just me.

 

[aerithgirl]

I'd keep the wapity personally, I'm not really a fan of the HL (wouldn't have much use for me) but the wapity has the handle and is shaped better IMO.

 

[heychar]

I prefer the Wapity!

 

[19flowers]

I like the Wapity much better than the Mini Sac HL.

 

[queennadine]

There's something I love about Mini Sac HL...I don't know what it is, but I just love it!

I think it's adorable! That would be my choice

 

[KPKITTY]

Wapity for me!

 

[sparklemint]

I also prefer the Wapity.. I owned both, I sold the HL and still have the Wap.
The HL is sweet, but impractical IMO!