Hi there! I am new around here, but I just wanted to give some advice to anyone looking to purchase the Princetown mules, Brixton loafers, or Jordaan loafers!
It has been a headache trying to figure out my sizing (reading through countless reviews, watching YouTube reviews, checking through this forum, etc) and I hope I can help anyone with my personal experience just so you don't have to go through what I did. I went through a lot of exchanging, returning, waiting for stock, being patient etc etc before I found the perfect sizes bc I am quite picky!
So I usually always take a 7.5 US and usually a 38 in European sizes. To reference popular shoes I am a 38N in Birkenstock Arizonas, a 7.5 in classic Converse, 38 in Stan Smith's, and a 38 in the Acne Studios Jensen boots. I would say I have a narrow-ish to regular width foot.
However, in both the Brixton and Jordaan styles, much to my surprise I found size 37 was the size that fit best. I tried on the 38 and they were massive. Then the 37.5, which fit well, but I feared with the leather stretching they would become too loose, I think. Lastly, I tried size 37 and they fit like a glove! They did not feel tight at all and I experienced no blisters or rubbing even in the beginning with the first couple of wears. I know a lot of you have said the Jordaans run narrower, but in my opinion I do not feel much of a difference between the Brixton. The leather is softer on the Brixton, but I feel the fit is quite similar if not identical for me. All in all, I would say get these half a size smaller than your US size.
Something else I wanted to mention. The Brixton's are VERY delicate, so delicate that the leatner inside the sole of my shoe started to peel off on the edges.... like the adhesive was wearing off after only having the shoes for a month. I am pretty sure the pair I had were defective, as I complained and returned them right away. I was SO sad that this happened. Fortunately, I don't think I've encountered anyone else saying they had this same issue, so it could've just been me.
After this happened, I decided to go for the Jordaan's as they seem sturdier and will hold up better. So if anyone is debating between the two loafer styles, I say go for the Jordaan even though they're more expensive I think it is worth it, unless you absolutely need a softer leather bc your feet are sensitive.
In the Princetown mules (w/o fur), again much to my surprise I take a size 38. I had originally purchased a 37 thinking they would fit like the loafers, but no. My foot hung off quite a bit! I then ordered a 37.5... still too small. I've read that a lot of people complain about how narrow this shoe is and how it's hard to get their foot all the way in. For me the width was fine, but even with pushing my toes all the way to the front in the 37.5 my heel still wasn't flush with the shoe. Thus, I went for the 38. Perfect fit no complaints! These were true to my European size.
I really hope this helps someone out there and saves someone the headache of trying to figure out your size!
