I am in love with an Omega watch at the moment and generally prefer the bigger, chunkier watches of today. However, I bought THIS watch 25 years ago and it is still in great condition and working perfectly. I wore it every single day for about 20 years and still wear it occasionally now. I also have a Stainless Steel Gucci that I now wear almost every day. Gucci watches may come from a Fashion House and they may only come in quartz, but that's not to say that they are not hardy and robust. Out of your two choices, my advice is to get the watch that feels best and most attractive on your wrist.