Return oxblood. Keep red and olive?This would be my everyday bag in the fall... so probably the Olive... UGH
Gone Rogue!!!!
- Thread starter sad16480
- Start date
TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others
This would be my everyday bag in the fall... so probably the Olive... UGH
Hi again, I saw your reply in the other thread too... we must both be online right now.
I know, it is actually a big deal to choose these things! Maybe you should go with the color you love, especially if Olive is UGH for you (unless you already have 50 other red bags)! 
I actually have the Medium Cornflower (with tags on it) and the Saddle 25 (with tags on it)... I didn't think about one of those... hmmm.... I think the Saddle above might look like Oxblood
Hi again, I saw your reply in the other thread too... we must both be online right now.
My SA knows me well, and when I reconsider a bag (like I am with the Olive), she says I should just exchange it! I only have a very small red bag that would fit my phone, nothing substantial... Thanks for your thoughts!!!!!
I actually have the Medium Cornflower (with tags on it) and the Saddle 25 (with tags on it)... I didn't think about one of those... hmmm.... I think the Saddle above might look like Oxblood
FWIW, I know many people love the Cornflower, but I had one (I had to return it anyway because it was damaged, yada yada), and I wasn't actually too crazy about it in person; I would have exchanged for a different color if I hadn't thought it was just a bit too heavy for extended carrying.
If you have other bags that are neutral, like your saddle one.... Go for red! It looks like a "happy bag"! And that dark burgundy interior makes it pop!
Okay, you have all convinced me... Red it is!!!
Oh you've decided and I was about to add my two cents. I was going to vote for red too. I don't think Coach makes that many red bags so if you love red I would go for it. I have 2 olive bags already so I've been debating whether or not to get the olive rogue too. I think olive would come back in another style at some point if you are in love with the color.
Okay, you have all convinced me... Red it is!!!
I'm glad to hear. More importantly, I hope it's love for you.
I am wondering if they got rid of the lock to lighten the weight. They did upgrade the zipper, though. More substantial than the zipper in the original batch. Just bought the stunning chalk Rogue with the red edge stain and brass. Beautiful...Congratulations! Beautiful choices.
I have the Olive on order..... thanks for the heads-up that it's also missing the lockA little disappointed - why does Coach do that??? A nice elevated touch - then wooossshh.... next batch it's gone!
I will tomorrow. In bed already. 😊 The photo on the website for the chalk ($795) is not correct. It shows pewter hardware on the hang tag and no red edge stain. If you look at the chalk 25 Rogue photo, that is exactly the colorway. And sadly, no lock. It is not on any of the new colors, I believe. The zippers are new. Thicker, more substantial on the pull. Another reason why the lock may have been excluded. It wouldn't fit on the new zipper pull. I like the new zipper better. Don't like that the lock is gone. Was told this colorway was produced in a very limited quantity. Saw the Dinky Tea Rose in chalk too. It also has the same colorway. Chalk with red piping. Same on limited quantity production. If you wanted anything in chalk, just sayin...:doggie::doggie: