They are similar but different because of the diff sole and star color. Do you see yourself wearing both because they’re diff enough? For me that would be the question. If I said no I’d keep the one i liked the most and would wear the most. I have 7 pairs. It came up earlier in the thread, I think Sinyard has 80+ pairs.
I have a black suede pair and just got those hi star ones in black and am looking at a black glitter pair. I should consider the hi star in white but I’m not sure I’d wear them enough to make it worthwhile.
I wish I had 80 + pairs lol! I sold a ton to make room for new ones. I think I have about 23 pairs now.... ♀️