Hi! I need some help....I bought a pair of Women's Superstar Leather and Mesh Sneakers in a 39 (I wear a size 9 show) after wearing them around the house all day they are NOT comfortable. It feels like something is pressing down on my pinky toes...I can't tell if I need a bigger size or I just need to wear them in but it's hard to keep a pair of 480$ shoes that aren't comfortable! Any advice or suggestions?View attachment 3907317
All of mine are perfect out of the box, including that exact pair. You might need to size up to a 40.