First Offer - What would you choose?

Which would you choose

  • B25 Noir GHW

    Votes: 131 64.9%

  • B30 Etain PHW

    Votes: 71 35.1%
  • Total voters
    202

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

#31
I’ve had both and if you don’t carry much, the B25 noir ghw is more desireable I think. I’ve carried both filled up to the brim and the B30 isn’t that heavy, (b35 is heavy) and B25 can suprisingly carry alot. But.... it’s the handle drop that turned me off from the b25. I like to be able to carry my bag up to the crook of my arm and not just handheld. I have big wrists so the b25’s handles can’t go up further than that. That was an expensive mistake made, and even though I love the look of a b25 I had to rehome it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: litostar
#32
swiftie1213 said:
What an amazing offer.
I would grab the B25 and run!!
The reason being, the B30 is very heavy. It is about 1 kilogram, so I found it to be too heavy even when it’s empty.
If you travel by car, and can put your bag down when you shop/go out, then i think a B30 is good.
If you don’t have a lot of stuff to carry around with you, I would take B25. Just make sure you check how far it goes up your arm. For me, it goes all the way up to the crook of my arm, so it’s not awkward to carry around.
All in all, team B25 all the way :smile:
Click to expand...
haha too funny! I’m watching lots of comparison videos! Although my SA did make a good point, she’s like “nobody’s waiting for the bus carrying a birkin” so weight shouldn’t be too much of an issue, but I mean if it’s a day of shopping I think it would still matter!

HKsai said:
B30 if you are only gonna have one Birkin. B25 if you intend to get more birkins in the future. I love b25 but it just doesn’t give the classic Birkin tote look when compared to a b30.
Click to expand...
Thanks for your input! I do agree that b30 is that size that is safe too and would always stay a classic and b25 is smaller and let’s say still “new”. Who knows, I may have both size eventually!
 
#33
chicfinds said:
definitely B25! I don’t think the mini bag trend will ever really go away (might be an unpopular opinion here...) but plenty of people (myself included) who don’t carry much day to day. B25 actually fits a lot and like others have said, the only con is that it won't fit comfortably on the crook of your arm. B25 is the best size imo and even as big bags are making a comeback, i would choose a lighter bag over a heavier bag any day. B30s look great and all but not the most ideal bag to be running around all day in - it just gets way too heavy.
Click to expand...

thank you! I also agree that since I don’t carry much I don’t see why I’d need such a big bag, so honestly I’ll be doing my reveal soon hehe

Siha77 said:
My gf who owns both told me I should definitely go B25 because the B30 is surprisingly heavy. I’m SO glad I listened because I’m obsessed with my B25. The handles are not an issue for me, I’m still able to arm carry if I need to. It’s been such a great daily bag even during the pandemic because I just toss things in and go without having to fuss with flaps, clasps, etc. I don’t carry much with me so it’s the perfect size for me, small bag trend or not. Even the B25 in Togo leather has some surprising weight to it, so I’m glad I didn’t go for the B30. As someone else here said, take the B25 and run! Especially in such a classic combo! Show us the reveal whatever you decide! *Edit: I saw that you’re 5’5. I’m 5’6 and the bag is absolutely perfect for me.
Click to expand...
Right? The b30 is heavy! But I mean since the small bag trend I’ve went from LV NF tote size bags to Chanel minis so I’ve definitely learned to downsize so maybe that’s why I think it’s so heavy haha thanks for your height reference!


img said:
I am very sensitive to weight of bags and my B30 doesn't bother me AT ALL. I have Togo and don't find it to be heavy but I don't carry much, either. I'm 5'2" and 115 pounds.
B30 is the quintessential size IMO so that gets my vote.

That said, you can't make a wrong choice here.
Click to expand...
Interesting how each one of us perceives as heavy! I think you’re right that the b30 is the quintessential size but maybe, just maybe the b25 will work for me
 
#34
elle woods said:
Congratulations on the amazing offers, I remember you asking about getting a store offer earlier this year, so glad you were able to get not just one, but two, so soon! I really don't think you can go wrong with either option. I love the B30 size personally as I have two small kids so I need to be able to slip it onto the crook if my arm if needed. I don't have a B25 but have held one and it is surprisingly roomy. I agree with your approach, I think try them on and bring your K28 to compare. Share pics and keep us posted!
Click to expand...
Yes I’m so fortunate to have been given offers so soon! And thank you so much for your advice/input/info you shared regarding H Canada! I don’t feel my K28 up often so I’d imagine I wouldn’t either for the B30. I will definitely be sharing what I end up getting!

Ethengdurst said:
I’ve had both and if you don’t carry much, the B25 noir ghw is more desireable I think. I’ve carried both filled up to the brim and the B30 isn’t that heavy, (b35 is heavy) and B25 can suprisingly carry alot. But.... it’s the handle drop that turned me off from the b25. I like to be able to carry my bag up to the crook of my arm and not just handheld. I have big wrists so the b25’s handles can’t go up further than that. That was an expensive mistake made, and even though I love the look of a b25 I had to rehome it.
Click to expand...
Thank you for your input! And this is what I might be afraid of is if I get one over the other I might not be using it for different reasons and regret it so that’s why I’m so torn!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bereal and elle woods
#36
Finally have time to post! And some of you may have already guessed from how I responded, I picked up this beauty! B25 Noir GHW! B25 is a lot smaller in person tbh but it’s so cute! The bag fits halfway up my arm, not to the crook but I think I’d use the top handle more. I’m very happy as when I saw the colour combo I knew I much preferred the classic black as my first bag over etain!
 

Attachments

  • 1699FAE1-E0B5-4792-BA56-89F4DB921F10.jpeg
    1699FAE1-E0B5-4792-BA56-89F4DB921F10.jpeg
    343.9 KB · Views: 65
  • Like
  • Love
  • Wow
Reactions: Bereal, eckw, onehotlatte and 23 others
#37
litostar said:
Finally have time to post! And some of you may have already guessed from how I responded, I picked up this beauty! B25 Noir GHW! B25 is a lot smaller in person tbh but it’s so cute! The bag fits halfway up my arm, not to the crook but I think I’d use the top handle more. I’m very happy as when I saw the colour combo I knew I much preferred the classic black as my first bag over etain!
Click to expand...
That is gorgeous! Congratulations again!
 
  • Like
Reactions: litostar
#38
Congrats! You’ve a classic beauty. I’ve been following this thread as K’s are my favorite but I’m challenging myself to break the mode this year with maybe something else...soon. Congrats congrats again. You’ve really given this much thought. Enjoy your B25 :flowers:
 
  • Like
Reactions: litostar
#40
elle woods said:
That is gorgeous! Congratulations again!
Click to expand...
Thank you so much!!

sf_newyorker said:
Congrats! You’ve a classic beauty. I’ve been following this thread as K’s are my favorite but I’m challenging myself to break the mode this year with maybe something else...soon. Congrats congrats again. You’ve really given this much thought. Enjoy your B25 :flowers:
Click to expand...

Thank you! Ohh something else soon as in you will be getting a b soon too? I actually love Ks more and for me this will be a challenge so I hope it goes well! Thank you again!

H Ever After said:
Beautiful bag and sounds like the right choice for you. I would have picked this one too. Congrats and enjoy in good health!!
Click to expand...

thank you! Let’s hope for a better 2021 so we can use our bags! You as well, happy holidays and all the best!
 
#41
litostar said:
Finally have time to post! And some of you may have already guessed from how I responded, I picked up this beauty! B25 Noir GHW! B25 is a lot smaller in person tbh but it’s so cute! The bag fits halfway up my arm, not to the crook but I think I’d use the top handle more. I’m very happy as when I saw the colour combo I knew I much preferred the classic black as my first bag over etain!
Click to expand...
beautiful! enjoy wearing her-she will never go out of style!
You can wear this bag until you're old and grey :heart:
 
  • Like
Reactions: litostar
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top