Agreeing with everything recently said - there's nothing like an aged brown leather, and I would wear brown any day over black.
Here are my brown leather beauties (not including my straw bag and LV canvas). I'll keep both of these forever and ever.
The backpack is from a little shop in Sorrento, Italy. I bought it almost 10 years ago on a high school trip, and I felt guilty buying such an "expensive" item on my parents' dime, so I got the simplest shape with no pockets… for €40!!!! When I got home and showed it to them, they told me I should've bought more; bless them for always geing so generous with me. It has been through hell and back because I used to think you could wear leather in the rain and I always put it on the floor. Every inch is covered in scratches and discolorations and the brass is so tarnished, but the stitching has never come apart and the leather still smells as rich and amazing as the day bought it in that open-air shop down a street in Italy. I should have bought ten more bags based on how well this one has served me and how beautifully it aged.
Fast forward and my other brown bag is my Dooney alto Valentina, which was a far cry from the €40 I agonized over as a teen LOL. This is my baby that still makes me so excited when I see it and makes me feel like a queen when I wear it. The leather smells just like my backpack, and it's also made in Italy. It's on its way to collecting a lovely patina. The shape is so classic and pretty and timeless that I'm so excited to using it for years to come. I'm against buying myself duplicates when there are so many great bags and brands out there, but this is my one bag I really have to fight myself and not get it in all three sizes