Both claim to be vintage leather box Kelly 32 handbags yet one is stamped "Hermes Paris" while the other is "Hermes Paris Made in France"... could one of them be a fake?
I think bags made in different years have different markings, post the information at the Authenticate thread, the lovely ladies there will be able to help u.
Theoretically yes but I have seen vintage Kellys without any of those - it doesn't mean they aren't authentic, it just means that they were well loved in their past life. But it does add up if you have to buy a replacement key, lock, and tirette/clochette from Hermès.