Elizabeth and James Olivia Poncho Coat - yes or no?

[KristyDarling]

Hi all!

I have a thing for E&J jackets but sometimes there's a seed of doubt. What do you think of this? I think it's cool but there's a part of me that can't help but think of hair salon smocks. What do you think, yes or no?

http://www.tobi.com/product/21648-elizabeth-and-james-olivia-poncho-jackets-casual?color_id=26052

TIA!
Kristy

 

[lv-lover]

No. I like the cut, but the fabric is too hair salon smock-y.

 

[IrisCole]

No. I like the cut, but the fabric is too hair salon smock-y.

Agreed -- and even on sale, this jacket is still a pretty penny. I think you could find something much cuter for that price.

 

[PurseAddict79]

I'd pass.

 

[lil_peanut]

Not at that price.

 

[bubbleloba]

It's a no for me.

 

[KristyDarling]

LOL, looks like it's a consensus thus far! Thanks for validating my doubts!!

 

[Flip88]

I'm not a fan TBH

 

[payo1a]

i've seen sweaters/shawls like that that works, but it's usually a jersey/cotton/knit material. is the ribbed sleeve part of it too? i'd pass on this particular one too.

if you do decide to get something similar, wear it with a light coloured long sleeve underneath for contrast.

 

[juneping]

Agreed -- and even on sale, this jacket is still a pretty penny. I think you could find something much cuter for that price.

good points!!

 

[dreamdoll]

It's a no for me too.

 

[airborne]

sorry no, ...it looks too much like what my hair dresser wear when she's doing my hair...but if you like im happy for you...

 

[sonya]

I'm not really a fan.

 

[Sarah Lizzie]

Nay from me too! ^I agree with the hair salon comparisons!

 

[Jeneen]

no no no

I'd go with a trench over that any day!