I vote for HW too as it sounds like that's what you love. This is coming from someone who got the Tiffany Soleste for our 10 yr anniv. upgrade and LOVE it. You have to go with what you love. I thought the HW micropave was stunning but at the end of the day we don't live in a city with an HW and the Soleste had been my dream ring for a long time. If I had pined for the HW longer and it was in my city things may be different. I've had my ring cleaned at the store multiple times since its purchase and we're on very good terms with our SA so my experience could not have been more positive but this was my dream ring despite liking the HW very much as well. I wear a size 3 so a little over 1ct with the halos has ample finger coverage and personally this ring already garners more attention that I'd like, DH regrets not going even bigger and if he had gone bigger I'm sure I would have loved that too but I'm not sure how comfortable I would be wearing it about if it were any bigger.