I agree with you that the red rogue needs some contrast. I like your choices with the black handles and the antique nickel hardware.
Thanks; I think I'll ask for a pic of the actual materials together. I'm sure about the red body and straps, the black handles and the nickel hardware; I'm just not sure what suede to get. None of the choices seem perfect to me. Red and Indigo are the best, I think, but it's hard to tell from the simulated pictures.
I only want one more Rogue; so I want to choose very carefully. I adored the Steel Blue when I saw it (the lining made it for me), but I think Red might be more timeless.
I do also have a 36 in Saddle but I wear that as a shoulder bag and really consider it to be a tote, mainly for vacations or skating competitions when I want to stuff in gloves, scarf, maybe a thin sweater, etc. I don't see it as a daily bag.