Just guessing, maybe they'd been tried on too many times or weren't handled well on Barneys end.Yeah, I can definitely take a picture of the other small tear on the insole... worried it will get worse with wear, but it's very small right now. Will upload once I get home!
The Convu sandals with the big insole issue, I got them from Barneys.com but decided to email Manolo Blahnik about it first and this was their response, emphasis mine:
Thank you for your email.
I am very sorry to see this happen to your shoes.
Please be aware that all repairs, returns and exchanges need to be processed through the original place of purchase and is subject to assessment.
I advise you to take the shoes back to Barneys for assessment.
All assessments are at the discretion of the retail store and you will require the receipt.
Please note that repairs for manufacturing faults are usually provided within twelve months of purchase.
Alternatively you will need to seek the guidance of a shoe repairer or cobbler.
If you need any further information please let me know.
And when I said to bring them back to the boutique where you bought them, I meant place of purchase. They are the ones responsible for the issue. The manufacturer really can't be held responsible for any mishandling at place of purchase.
The pictures of that innersole are really a minor repair. It's too bad this happened to your first Manolo's but this is not at all representative of his shoes (which are all hand made).