Decisions, Decisions

[Cristina]

So I have narrowed it down to two. Vast price difference, I know. Here are the two bags I am thinking of buying. The other one will go on my Christmas list.



Coach Hamptons Leather Satchel
Pros:
I LOVE the color. Not a very practical color, I know. But I've never been one to choose go-with-everything bags. I wear it even if it doesn't match very well
The size seems just right. Not a huge overwhelming tote, but big enough to fit my things and more and not look overstuffed.

Cons:
The color. Once and for all, should I invest in something that goes with everything?
I already have a Coach bag and wrislet. Maybe I should venture out and go for a different brand?




Luella Gisele Mini

Pros:
The camel color matches so many of my outfits, and I know of a couple of pairs of shoes I have that would look great with this bag. I don't have a brown bag (yet).
I love the silver hardware and grommets.
It's just darn cute!

Cons:
It's small, but I think I could deal. My Burberry small tote is not too much bigger than this and I haven't had a problem with it being too stuffed.
I know it's sort of an "it" bag. But if it goes "out" that doesn't mean I would stop carrying it. If it's good quality and will last long, then I know the purchase was worth it even if it's not in every fashion magazine.


Opinions? Suggestions? Thanks

 

[Issmom]

I LOVE my Gisele (its beige canvas and green leather) but its a BABY not a MINI. I like the MINI but I kinda think the hearts are too big for it.

I'm not a big Coach fan but I like that one. And I think the color is great.

If you wouldn't consider the larger Gisele, I say buy the Coach.

 

[pseub]

Nothing worse than a bag that ends up being too small for what you need. The Coach has a more classic shape, and a nice color. You'd probably use that one for years. The other one is more whimsical but very cute. My vote would go to the Coach.

 

[Cristina]

The Coach also comes in this color:



Which I do like, and it might go with a lot more. That teal is so eye-catching, though

 

[pseub]

Either color is nice. IMHO, the teal is more year-round. I like the claret though.

 

[Cristina]

Okay, leaning more toward the Coach cos of practicality and the cool color. Anyone else have input? My Visa is ready to go

 

[kojiko]

Why not get a Luella Gisele Mini? Spice it up! hehe

 

[Gracie]

I actually like the Coach - the color and the classic shape.

 

[Cristina]

Okay, I've decided to splurge and go for the Luella Mini, even though it's small. I can't pass it up! Also, since it's more $$$ than the Coach, I know that I have a better chance of putting the Coach bag on my wishlist and actually getting it for Christmas. I e-mailed the picture, price and where to find it to the bf :embarasse At least he doesn't have to worry about buying expensive jewelry - I'd rather get a new bag!

 

[Issmom]

If that's the logic, then yes, go for the Gisele. The BF is more likely to buy the Coach anyway.

 

[heavensent]

good choice , even though i would did it the other way around lol

 

[Cristina]

Haven't bought anything yet - I'm going shopping tomorrow with my mom and grandmother. Knowing me, I might come back with something completely different! I'll have a full report with photos