I have this problem too. To me Blush would be adventurous lol I will add i do own one unusual colored bag in what i would describe as a Kelly green(it's by Roots) but generally i am neutral all the way, i admire the colors but cannot pull the trigger!
I had a few colored Jet set crossbodies to choose from could NOT do it, the pale blue was as exciting as i could do, but with it s/o in two closest stores, peanut became it.
I still long for blush, an Ava blush love that bag but my winters are long and brutal so not sure i could get enough use from that color. sigh. such a dilemma lol