Hi all. I really need your advice. I seem to have run into trouble with the Legacy Rambler I had gotten authenticated here in the forum. Based on the seller's photos I didn't suspect anything was amiss and bought it, hoping to give it to my mother for Christmas. When it arrived it looked a bit dry, but I was always planning to dunk it to give it back some shape. This is when it all started. First I think I just gave it a wipe with a wet towel which revealed that it was staining when wet. I then decided to first give it the saddle soap treatment (yellow Fiebing's) that would give it some initial moisture, conditioning and would also let me assess how extensive the staining was. At that point it felt like it was the whole bag. I dunked it with some really gentle dish soap and gave it a brush and the first water I had in the container didn't turn opaque, but it turned quite dark. The two consecutive refills gradually less so. So I thought I had gotten it under control and that it was perhaps just some thing that had remained on the bag's surface and finally started to come off. Wrong. It had been drying for a while when I wanted to assess the situation. As soon as it got wet/saddle soap on it again, it started staining again, intensively. So I decided to first avoid any harsh chemicals and decided to see how far I would get with the saddle soap, since whatever was on the bag also came off when using it. I was able to make out that the main problem areas of the bag are the flap and the back side of the bag, the strap as well, but less so. The sides, bottom and front of the bag under the flap seem to be mostly unaffected. What I would do was that I would wet my horsehair brush, get some saddle soap on there and then brush the leather as one does, then wipe off the lather which showed how stained it was. I did that many times, until I saw that the leather was becoming lighter on the flap, but uniformly, not as in more worn patches etc. It started feeling like I was doing more harm than good and not knowing if there would even be getting it (what is that even?) all off I decided to stop and let it dry completely. I initially gave it a coat of Uniters Leather Protection Cream (silicone free, of course) and while that didn't really hide the discoloration I hoped it would offer the initially conditioning and would also make it less likely to stain. It was staining less, but still....it didn't do anything for the discoloration. So I got the Safir Medaille d'Or Renovateur (colourless), specifically the one that is mink oil based, in hopes it would darken the leather as promised. The bag now has a coat of it on and even two in those problem areas, buffed in. But the thing is that, when I applied it, it immediately started staining again. I am hoping that if I let it sit and absorb and dry, it will be sealed somehow. It really did the trick and you really have to look for any discoloration, BUT if it still stains anytime it gets wet I still have a big problem to solve.
So now I'm left with a bunch of questions. Has this at all ever been an issue with vintage unlined
Coach bags? Even ones that haven't been dyed with who knows what? In case this has been dyed/painted (with who knows what) what should I do now? Is this a losing battle or is there something I can still try? Should I just keep adding more layers of Safir Renovateur or is there another type of product that can seal in whatever is going on with the dye?
I know this is long as hell, but thank you for getting through it and I appreciate any and all thoughts.
PS: One mistake I made was not take photos of all the stages, but here are some photos of the bag post Saphir attached.