Hi rehabbers,
I've finished my saddle pouch (which I thought was British Tan but now I'm not so sure; posted query over on Authenticate thread) and after all my anxiousness about it I'm really pleased with the results!
Even though it lost that stiff glossiness from when I bought it, it really looks better now because it is obviously cleaner and the leather is softer and much more even-toned.
I'll post some before and after pictures below.
Thanks everyone for your help! This is my fourth bag and I'm quite addicted.
The first three are before pics. It wasn't in terrible shape.
The second three are the after pics. (I don't know how to comment in-between photo uploads.)